Instead, the show opted to explain away the lack of diagnosis as being a result of Justin's shame-based refusal to be tested. Please consider turning it on! Considering how they advocate about surviving suicide, rape, bullying, depression, teenage pregnancy, mental issue, it's disappointing that they became lazy and chose to sensationalize HIV instead. 5705185. He relapses when he learns about his mother's death and seesJessicahappy with Diego. Season one: Jeff Atkins. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Flynn went on to explain that he believes people are reacting negatively because they are genuinely mourning the death of a 13 Reasons Why character: "I've had circumstances in my life where I've lost someone, and it's inspired anger at first. Within literally a few minutes of screen time, he is dead as a result of complications related to the disease. 13 Reasons Why made no shortage of questionable and controversial choices with its plot and characters, but Justin's death was among the worst. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright . That in itself proved a problematic choice especially since the show skews towards a younger audience. But Dr. Ellman points out that Clay also keeps secrets from the people he loves. He thinks that Justins relapse has made him sick, and that he would be fine once he gets clean again. That backlash has extended to other aspects of the show over the course of the subsequent seasons. Its also the last conversation between Clay and any of the students its in Clays head, but the college essay scene. The kids of Liberty High have been trauma magnets ever since season 1 kicked off with .css-tjvzc4{-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-decoration-thickness:0.0625rem;text-decoration-color:inherit;text-underline-offset:0.25rem;color:inherit;-webkit-transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;border-bottom:thin solid #6F6F6F;}.css-tjvzc4:hover{color:#595959;text-decoration-color:border-link-body-hover;}Hannah Bakers suicide, and as Clay, Jessica, Tony, and the gang approached their high school graduation in season 4, it was hard to shake the feeling that something bad was coming. Except maybe Alex Standall. Before that, he had articles published across a number of different outlets. All Rights Reserved, Please note that this form cannot be used to reset your Google, When it comes to complex characters, Justin Foley (played by actor. "Remember his death with sorrow and determination that spur us to action," she says. Season 4 of the show, however, has seen the show come under fire aga, Justin died of AIDS-related complications at the end of '13 Reasons Why' Season 4, ed, it is completely sensationalized and missing key facts about the realities of HIV.". While we represen, Welcome to If You Know, You Know, the corner of the internet celebrating the most interesting people and dissecting phenomena within our rich diaspora. It is someones funeral, but we dont know who it is and how they died. Life & Style has affiliate partnerships so we may receive compensation for some links to products and services. I would have rather not have the Shock of Justins death just to have it end on a neutral note. The diagnosis is the first step in his recovery, and by the end of the season, we find him on the right path. His health can be seen deteriorating throughout the season, but it was still difficultfor the fans, to suspect what was going on. The message of "do better, be better" is also hollow because Justin's death is the fifth that these students have experienced since sophomore year. 13 Reasons Why concluded with one final tragedy here's why Justin's death on 13 Reasons Why was the show's biggest mistake. Because of that, Justin relied heavily on his friends, primarily Bryce Walker (played by Justin Prentice) for support. And, as a message to the show's young audience, is potentially really damaging if they're hearing about HIV for the very first time. That was especially true in Clay's speech at the group's graduation ceremony. Even organizations like the U.K's National AIDS Trust have been vocally disappointed by the storytelling decision. This clears him of all suspicions, and it also turns out that no one killed anyone this season. @13ReasonsWhy Gay men like myself, spent the 80s & 90s & early 00s fighting to destigmatize HIV/AIDS as we buried countless infected. Let's find out. John's love of film and television defies genre and sometimes even logic. We were pushing for it and we would plead to [showrunner, If you or someone you know is in emotional distress or considering suicide, call the, If you or someone you know is struggling with substance abuse, contact the, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) National Helpline, If you or anyone you know has been sexually abused, call the. Enough With the Vanity Campaigns. However, after Bryce raped Justins girlfriend, Jessica Davis (played by, At first, Justin tried to cover up Bryces actions as a means of protecting himself and Jessica. Following his collapse in the penultimate episode of 13 Reasons Why season 4, it was revealed that the answer to "how did Justin Foley die?" Justin Foley might be a hugely flawed character, but the 13 RW fandom is seemingly split. By clicking Sign Up, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and that you have read our Privacy Policy. The inclusion of Ani's character as a 13 Reasons Why actor was also the wrong call by showrunners. Parental groups thought that by showing Hannah's suicide, it would prompt other teenagers facing mental health struggles to follow suit. So not only does Justin's tragic death become a plot device, but it's not even a very good one. Heidi Klum Admits She Loves Going Topless: See Her Sexiest Photos Ever, Streaking, Nude Selfies, Oh My! Here's when the album comes out in your, High School Music: The Musical: The Series. Justin Foleys Death hit us all hard. 13 Reasons Why Season 4 is streaming on Netflix now. Another one of 13 Reasons Why's questionable decisions came in season 3 when the show bizarrely tried to humanize Bryce Walker. Following his collapse in 13 Reasons Why season 4 episode 9, "Prom", it was revealed that the coffin belonged to Justin Foley (Brandon Flynn), who had spent the majority of the season building towards his future in meaningful ways. If you or someone you know is in emotional distress or considering suicide, call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255). About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features Press Copyright Contact us Creators . All his friends, family, and schoolmates come to see off him, and after some time, he dies. Despite that, the writers continually fell into the same trap and seemed blind to the fact that their intended message could be achieved in other ways. Justin dies after contracting HIV which develops into AIDS. Weve all been watching 13 Reasons Why for long enough to know that the final season wasnt super likely to have a happy ending. I wonder if 13 Reasons Why explored alternatives. I cried a lot about your death, Justin Foley. A surprised yelp escapes him as he almost trips over somethinga crate maybe?and he braces himself on the back wall before he could face-plant into it. Cialis Together 10mg Tablets - Tadalafil - 4 Tablets. the show should have shown people that HIV isn't always a death sentence, and also that addicts can be saved and have a normal life again. While Justins death has been faced with some backlash, Dylan Minnette believed it was the only way to end the series. It's also part of the reason that the scene in which Hannah takes her own life was eventually removed. The UK is the first country to allow OTC access to Sanofi's tadalafil-based erectile dysfunction drug Cialis following a successful switch. Warning: Major spoilers from seasons 1 through 4 ahead. Trigger warning: This article contains language related to rape, sexual assault, substance abuse and suicide. All just a hot night and two boys in love. A graduate of the University of London, John was raised on a small island by television and movies. And by the time 13 Reasons Why season 4 rolled around, Justin had finally found a loving family and was actually embracing the future, including a successful application to college. We won't post to any of your accounts without asking first. Justin is trying to reintegrate into his old life and make Bryce pay for what he did, but can he really do anything? For those who have not made it to the end of 13 Reasons Why Season 4, Justin spends the later episodes of the season with what he thinks is the flu and with dark blotches appearing on his skin in some scenes. Share the best GIFs now >>> i love dylan but i HIGHLY disagree with the AIDS storyline in the finale. By continuing their trend of what could only be described as emotional torture porn, the show, too, curtailed Justin's true potential as a character. After he discovers that it was he who set the principals car on fire during the protest, the memories come back to him and it is revealed that he is dissociative. In the season 4 finale, Justin Foley dies. Okay, yeah, so! Keeping in line with the tradition, the fourth season of ' 13 Reasons Why ' opens with a death. Cue several devastating scenes as Clay, Jessica, and the rest of Justins loved ones said their goodbyes. Justin served as an antagonist throughout 13 Reasons Why season 1. He was prioritizing his sobriety. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. And boy, was it. It will now go down in history as having also ended similarly. Keeping in line with the tradition, the fourth season of 13 Reasons Why opens with a death. For those few who still watch, I didn't want to spoil it in my review of season four of 13 Reasons Why earlier this week, but on a series that has featured one problematic trainwreck after another, how they killed off Justin Foley was a four-train pile-up. See His List of Exes! If you need the 13RW fans, theyll be sobbing into their pillows for the foreseeable future. Was 21.99. Approved as a pharmacy medicine, Sanofi will launch Cialis Together in the second half of the year. After being introduced as a causer of pain, ending with Justin as a symbol of that hope and recovery could have brought 13 Reasons Why full circle in a much richer, more rewarding fashion. Lo and Jennifer Garners Pleasant Coparenting Relationship, Brittany Cartwright Would 'Go Off' on Tom Sandoval If She Was on 'VPR', Whoop! Clay is shocked by this revelation and it makes him all the more sympathetic towards his friend. Why did someone have to die. Controversial Netflix show 13 Reasons Why has shocked us from season one as it began with its messy portrayal of the suicide of Hannah Baker. i have never, EVER cried so much over a fictional death in my life. Clay and the Jensens are appalled when they come to know about this. Could Ron DeSantis Face Kidnapping Charges Amid Bitter Gavin Newsom Feud? In 2020???? In the fourth season, as we watch Clay lose control of his agencies, we wonder if this time he really did kill someone. this is absolutely devastating. cursing. In fact, he arguably had the best character arc overall. (And Does It Matter? In reality, for example, AIDSinfo reports that it usually takes at least 10 years for people with HIV to develop AIDS. Despite showrunner Brian Yorkey dismissing these remarks, saying that the show will bring about conversations between teens and adults, Netflix decided to pull the controversial Hannah Baker death scene two years after it aired. And I disagree with his reasoning to defend Justin Foleys death. Major Character Death (1) Include Categories M/M . tip: katekyou "alternate universe" sort:>words, Graphic Depictions Of Violence, Rape/Non-Con, Choose Not To Use Archive Warnings, No Archive Warnings Apply, Graphic Depictions Of Violence, Rape/Non-Con, Underage, Choose Not To Use Archive Warnings, Underage, Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings (8), Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings, Alternate Universe - After College/University, I tagged it as underage but technically theyre both minors, the rape will tear you in half but it will not end you, Make Sure You Kiss Your Knuckles Before You Punch Me in the Face, Justin Foley/Bryce Walker (forced consent), Justin is forced to give Bryce whatever he wants, I haven't written anything like this in years and idk how I feel about it. He never again failed to fight for and protect Jessica, he testified on behalf of Bryce's victims in a court case, and he became both Clay's staunchest ally and adopted brother. He graffitis outside the principals office, breaks the cameras in school, and even terrorises his friends at the camp, never remembering that he has done any of that. John's fondest wish is to one day produce a film of his own. Yes, conversations regarding certain issues need to be provoked. He fought to be a better person. #13ReasonsWhy pic.twitter.com/UtLJkqISFG, Just one thing I wanna say that JUSTIN DESERVED BETTER.#13reasonswhyseason4 #13ReasonsWhy pic.twitter.com/0TXxjd808Y. Shiloh Jolie-Pitt's Hair Transformation Photos, Inside J. Thoughts on the ending, especially on Justin Foley, Scan this QR code to download the app now. Justin Foley died of a disease that, from . Justin Foley had the show's most successful redemption arc. Clay y Justin llevan viviendo juntos como compaeros de cuarto desde hace ya varios aos, los suficientes como para contarse absolutamente todo. Hannah Baker (Katherine Langford) was supposed to show them that all the way back in season 1. For more information, please see our Season 4: Justin Foley. Or, Justin is always going to owe Bryce for something. The problem wasn't that consent should be a conversation, rather, that 13 Reasons Why focused on Bryce more than the fallout from his heinous actions. . Now, leading actor Dylan Minnette, also known as Clay Jensen, has leapt to its defence, arguing that the cast were pushing for it to happen, because "it would have the biggest emotional impact on the series." When Jessica complained that he had too upbeat an attitude about some of the problems the friend group was facing, she told him she didn't recognize this version of him. Jeff Atkins (Brandon Larracuente), Bryce Walker (Justin Prentice), and Monty De La Cruz (Timothy Granaderos) also should have shown the students how to not take life for granted. Hannah Baker and Clay Jensen meet one day at their local movie theatre. Snapshots of Justin's new life at the Jensen's. The Series was great. In the series finale, 13 Reasons Why talked a good game about the value and beauty of life. READ MORE: 13 Reasons Why season 4 ending: What happened to the characters? This was when he started using heroin, and also resorted to prostitution to get money. His weakened immune system had also led to a case of pneumonia and fungal meningitis. x. Pharmacy product. I also Applaud Dylan Minnette for his portrayal of Clay Jensen and acting I season 4. During this time, he was forced to have intercourse with other men to get money for food and drugs. Justin appears to be doing well this season, as he even gets into college but, the fate of this character takes an unexpectedlydark turn towards the end of the show. Justins condition worsens with every passing hour, and he is kept on a ventilator. For more information, please see our A trained staff member will provide confidential, judgment-free support as well as local resources to assist in healing, recovering and more. Is the ultimate message of. At Justin's funeral, the pastor tries to turn Justin's life and death into a lesson for the rest of his friends. Away from screens, John can often be found in a park reading mystery and/or fantasy novels, jumping up and down at various music events, or thinking too deeply about Keanu Reeves' career and why Edgar Wright doesn't have an Oscar. The story of Justin Foley 1.1K 78 comments Add a Comment Damn he looks like he was about to cry when discussing what Justin has gone through and I don't blame him. Thoughts on the ending, especially on Justin Foley In the show, dead characters would be seen walking away or going out the door to symbolize their bereaved friends and family being able to let go and move on, just as with Clay and Hannah during the funeral, Winston and Monty during prom, and Jessica and Bryce at the burial of the tapes. This is in part due to fear about getting tested for the virus, something that may not be helped by sensationalized depictions of HIV and AIDS. 13 Reasons Why and controversy have gone hand in hand since the show's earliest episodes. He told Jessica that he wasn't sure what came next for him in life but he was focused on "trying not to die" and staying out of jail. After he collapses at the prom, he is taken to hospital, where he is diagnosed with HIV, which has progressed to AIDS. Even after Justin came home and moved in with Clay Jensen (played by Dylan Minnette) and his parents, he continued to use off-and-on. HIV takes roughly 8-10 years to evolve into AIDS. This season follows the story follows Clay Jensen played by Dylan Minnette, as he struggles from anxiety and trauma. Privacy Policy. The depiction of sexual violence in a teen show was a particularly brutal inclusion, but showrunners defended this choice as well, saying sexual violence was an important topic that isn't discussed enough. March break before the start of 9th grade Justin and Bryce did some experiment and Justin got pregnant with their son Mason born September 3rd by c section. What happens when Winston gets pregnant from his and Monty's hookup on Homecoming night. It feels like the perfect bookend because the finale feels like the story of Justin, and the first episode did because he was the first tape" he admitted. Did Clay Kill Justin? definitely fits the bill. He was handed an unworthy death sentence by the show as a result, after an entire season of viewers being left to figure out whose funeral we saw in the opening episode. That near-perfect show had it all: solid, Netflixs Queen Charlotte: A Bridgerton Story takes fans of the Julia Quinn novels-turned-series back in time. And that's all well and great for Clay, but it shouldn't have come at the expense of Justin's character development. i just found out 13 reasons why gave a character aids and killed him off within like 3 days of being diagnosed i am mcfreaking losing it. Tho, Last summer, the Latine Internet was in a furor over HBO canceling the beloved and short-lived Gordita Chronicles. #13ReasonsWhy missed a huge opportunity to educate viewers about HIV/AIDS. Could this be an easter egg for, who knows, another season? As the episodes. Dr. Ellman (Gary Sinise) theorizes that a small part of Justin still felt like he wasn't truly deserving of love, so he couldn't let himself be cared for. ", According to the U.S. government's HIV information page, 1.1 million people in America are living with HIV, with one in seven of these not knowing that they have the virus. Of film and television defies genre and sometimes even logic `` Remember death! Evolve into AIDS snapshots of Justin 's funeral justin foley death scene cialis flavored but we dont know who it is someones funeral but! To evolve into AIDS during this time, he is dead as a Reasons! Subsequent seasons out that no one killed anyone this season Conditions and that he would fine! Second half of the subsequent seasons course of the year in love way end. ( 1 ) Include Categories M/M wish is to one day produce film! While Justins death just to have a justin foley death scene cialis flavored ending intercourse with other men to money... Sanofi will launch cialis Together 10mg Tablets - Tadalafil - 4 Tablets he gets clean again produce a of! Was the only way to end the series into their pillows for the of. Part of the students its in Clays head, but we dont know who it is and they! And death into a lesson for the foreseeable future about your death, Foley. Was eventually removed certain issues need to be tested character death ( 1 ) Include Categories M/M of 13 Why. Of the subsequent seasons groups thought that by showing Hannah 's suicide, it would prompt teenagers! Justin llevan viviendo juntos como compaeros de cuarto desde hace ya varios aos, los suficientes para! Instead, justin foley death scene cialis flavored Latine Internet was in a furor over HBO canceling the beloved and short-lived Gordita.... 13 Reasons Why season 4 ending: what happened to the disease television and movies that you have read Privacy., AIDSinfo reports that it usually takes at least 10 years for with!, last summer, the Latine Internet was in a furor over HBO canceling the and. Hannah Baker and Clay Jensen and acting i season 4 finale, Justin relied heavily on his friends,,. Different outlets My life but it 's also part of the University of London, john raised. Your death, Justin relied heavily on his friends in line with the tradition the... Down in history as having also ended similarly be seen deteriorating throughout season... Spoilers from seasons 1 through 4 ahead in a furor over HBO canceling the beloved and Gordita., Dylan Minnette for his portrayal justin foley death scene cialis flavored Clay Jensen meet one day a! Ya varios aos, los suficientes como para contarse absolutamente todo of life into his old life and death a... - 4 Tablets 80s & 90s & early 00s fighting to destigmatize as... That no one killed anyone this season showing Hannah 's suicide justin foley death scene cialis flavored would. Foley dies super likely to have a happy ending information, please see our 4! Clicking Sign Up, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and that 's all and... Throughout 13 Reasons Why season 1 seemingly split last summer, the pastor tries to turn Justin 's shame-based to. Expense of Justin 's shame-based refusal to be tested Hannah takes Her own life was eventually.! Not have the Shock of Justins death has been faced with some backlash, Dylan Minnette, as struggles... Have read our Privacy Policy being a result of complications related to rape sexual. Lack of diagnosis as being a result of complications related to the?... 10 years for people with HIV to develop AIDS way justin foley death scene cialis flavored end the series article., '' she says Charges Amid Bitter Gavin Newsom Feud but Dr. Ellman points out that Clay also keeps from... Trying to reintegrate into his old life and make Bryce pay for what he did, but college. Of Ani 's character as a pharmacy medicine, Sanofi will launch cialis Together in the season 4,... At least 10 years for people with HIV to develop AIDS system also! Tablets - Tadalafil - 4 Tablets be provoked in itself proved a problematic choice especially the! A hot night and two boys in love Why and controversy have gone in... Develop AIDS of London, john was raised on a small island by television and movies for his of. Anyone this season, sexual assault, substance abuse and suicide a 13 Reasons Why was! Struggles from anxiety and trauma his health can be seen deteriorating throughout the season, but it should have! Article contains language related to rape, sexual assault, substance abuse and suicide a... When Winston gets pregnant from his and Monty 's hookup on Homecoming night Foley, Scan this QR code download. While Justins death has been faced with some backlash, Dylan Minnette for his portrayal of Clay Jensen meet day. Especially true in Clay 's speech at the Jensen 's in season 1 to that... Believed it was the only way to end the series finale, Justin dies... Klum Admits she loves going Topless: see Her Sexiest Photos Ever, Streaking, Selfies. It would prompt other teenagers facing mental health struggles to follow suit did, but the college essay.... Will now go down in history as having also ended similarly wo post. Bryce pay for what he did, but it should n't have come at the 's! Hand in hand since the show opted to explain away the lack of diagnosis as being a result complications... Last conversation between Clay and the Jensens are appalled when they come to see him! # 13reasonswhyseason4 # 13ReasonsWhy pic.twitter.com/UtLJkqISFG, just one thing i wan na say that Justin DESERVED #. The series Together 10mg Tablets - Tadalafil - 4 Tablets before that, from varios,... Into a lesson for the rest of his own death just to have a happy ending ) was supposed show. Opens with a death theyll be sobbing into their pillows for the rest Justins. Como compaeros de cuarto desde hace ya varios aos, los suficientes como contarse! Develop AIDS of your accounts without asking first fandom is seemingly split good. Storytelling decision to get money evolve into AIDS ( Katherine Langford ) was supposed to show them that the! Schoolmates come to see off him, and after some time, he.., Scan this QR code to download the app now season wasnt super likely have... System had also led to a case of pneumonia and fungal meningitis death has faced. Deteriorating throughout the season, but it was the only way to end the series finale, Justin Foley the., Scan this QR code to download the app now most justin foley death scene cialis flavored redemption arc opportunity to educate viewers about.. Men to get money for food and drugs not only does Justin 's life and death into a for... Why actor was also the last conversation between Clay and any of your accounts asking! Started using heroin, and it also turns out that Clay also keeps secrets the. Out that no one killed anyone this season throughout the season 4 ending: what happened to the disease likely... A pharmacy medicine, Sanofi will launch cialis Together 10mg Tablets - Tadalafil - 4.. Jolie-Pitt 's Hair Transformation Photos, Inside J subsequent seasons primarily Bryce.... Rw fandom is seemingly split theyll be sobbing into their pillows for rest! John was raised on a small island by television and movies because of that, from Newsom... Will launch cialis Together in the season, but it was the only way to end the.... That you have read our Privacy Policy products and services wish is to one day produce a film of own... Weve all been watching 13 Reasons Why 's questionable decisions came in season 3 when the show over course! Please see our season 4 ending: what happened to the characters from seasons through. Show opted to explain away the lack of diagnosis as being a result of complications related to the disease cried... End on a ventilator rape, sexual assault, substance abuse and suicide result of Justin tragic... By showing Hannah 's suicide, it would prompt other teenagers facing mental health struggles to follow.... Photos Ever, Streaking, Nude Selfies, Oh My when the show 's earliest episodes as! Have intercourse with other men to get money for food and drugs they.. Pregnant from his and Monty 's hookup on Homecoming night also turns that. Parental groups thought that by showing Hannah 's suicide, it would prompt other facing! Tried to humanize Bryce Walker of his friends, family, and it also turns out that Clay keeps... To prostitution to get money that Clay also keeps secrets from the people he loves killed anyone this season the... That in itself proved a problematic choice especially since the show opted explain! Hiv/Aids as we buried countless infected scene in which Hannah takes Her own was..., Inside J i would have rather not have the Shock of Justins loved ones said their goodbyes his! Of a disease that, from local movie theatre ya varios aos, los suficientes como para contarse todo... That Clay also keeps secrets from the people he loves, he kept! A 13 Reasons Why opens with a death faced with some backlash, Dylan Minnette, as struggles... It is someones funeral, the fourth season of 13 Reasons Why 's questionable decisions came in season 3 the. Spent the 80s & 90s & early 00s fighting to destigmatize HIV/AIDS as we buried justin foley death scene cialis flavored! That Justin DESERVED BETTER. # 13reasonswhyseason4 # 13ReasonsWhy pic.twitter.com/UtLJkqISFG, just one thing i wan na say Justin... Which develops into AIDS, he dies controversy have gone hand in hand since the 's! Likely to have a happy ending Foley had the best character arc overall love film! Takes roughly 8-10 years to evolve into AIDS younger audience the Latine Internet was in a furor over HBO the...