Judge Gomez 3.6 All Appellate Judges 3.5 Writing (Attorneys) 3.6 3.3 Inter-Judge Evaluation 3.7 3.7 Summary of Responses Detailed Report General Evaluation Questions (Attorneys) 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 Judge Gomez Overall 3.6 Appellate Judges Overall 3.5 The system has its critics, in part because its rare for a judge to be booted by voters. The group has also advocated the addition of public testimony to the commissions process. Honorable Patrick H. Pugh. Here's a guide to help you sort those ballots ahead of the November 8 election. More Information. If a judge has been put on an improvement plan, youll know about that too. To take the easy route, just go to the Colorado Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation website and select your county to see the judges on your ballot along with their ratings (all positive this year). 2 East 14 Avenue. Copyright 2023, All Rights Reserved | Colorado keeps complaints and resulting disciplinary action confidential, except in rare cases when a judge is publicly reprimanded or removed by the state Supreme Court. Nonpartisan commissions assess all the judges on the ballot and issue. The first paragraph always substantiates the recommendation of the Performance Committee and its distribution of votes. Christina Finzel Gomez is Judge at Colorado Court of Appeals. If the commission were to advise against keeping no one had that fate this year the judges answer would be included at the end. Experienced. She assumed office on May 31, 2019. Thereafter, judges re-stand for detention every four years (for circuit judges), six years (for circuit judges), or eight years (for circuit court judges). Impartial commissions evaluate each judge on the ballot and issue simple recommendations on each judge or Colorado Supreme Court justice up for retention, along with more information if youre willing to educate yourself. We support limited, fiscally responsible government that adheres to the Constitution, protects individual and property rights, promotes lower taxes, free enterprise, personal freedom and responsibility. Honorable Emily C. Lieberman. The governor fills vacancies in courts through the appointment of Supreme Court judges, Court of Appeals judges, and county and county court judges. This information may include negative impressions from the judge or concerns raised by the Commission in the past, along with the manner in which the judge responded. That means Denver voters will be asked to vote yes or no on 21 judges. The only exception is the city and county of Denver, where the city mayor appoints the judges of the Denver County Court (but not the judges of the Denver District Court). It's time you got to know her a little. One factor is that the names are unfamiliar to the average voter, making it difficult to make an informed decision. Since then, weve been doing that with 231 commissioners (who serve on panels) who assess the condition of judges in Colorado and really just serve to give voters some information about the judges performance.. Ten-person commissions evaluate county and district judges in each of the 22 judicial districts. If you are interested in learning more about the judges, both the state website and the Big Book, an informational pamphlet about the elections that is mailed to every voter before each election, provide the full ratings for each judge or magistrate on your local ballot. Its up to you, as voters weigh such information differently. Two years earlier, voters had rejected two judges the only ones to receive a Not Up To Performance Standards rating from the commissions. Retention Year: 2022 Recommendation: Meets Performance Standard Reports: 2022 Retention Survey Report 2021 Interim Survey Report The State Commission on Judicial Performance finds that Judge Matthew D. Grove MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS, by a vote of 11 - 0. She won in the retention election on November 8, 2022. Voters play an initial role two years after an appointment, deciding whether to keep or fire recently appointed individuals for the state higher courts and the lower courts of the judicial district or county in which they live. 2031 Years in position 3 Elections and appointments Last elected November 8, 2022 Appointed December 2, 2019 Contact Official website Personal Facebook Sueanna Johnson is a judge of the Colorado Court of Appeals. From 2016 - 2019, Judge Brown served as a District Court Judge in the 17th Judicial District (Adams and Broomfield Counties) where she presided over domestic relations and civil matters. The eighth, Terry Fox, was appointed in 2011 and is scheduled to take over on a regular basis. Fox was appointed by Democratic Governor Bill Ritter on September 1, 2010. Issuing opinions in a timely manner Making decisions without regard to possible criticism Making reasoned decisions based upon the law and facts Refraining from reaching issues that need not be decided The state provides voters with help Colorado has an evaluation process that offers information and evaluations on judges. But its also because citizen review commissions, set up to fill this information gap, rarely find a judge failing to meet performance standards. Phone: 720-625-5305. Her current term ends on January 13, 2031. And how do I vote on them? Judges here are appointed to the bench in state and county courts, rather than elected. Oct 27, 2022 Updated Nov 4, 2022 0 Judge Christina F. Gomez speaks on June 30, 2022 after her formal swearing-in to the Colorado Court of Appeals, with Chief Judge Gilbert M. Romn at right. Heres a guide to help you sort those ballots ahead of the November 8 election. The Colorado Court of Appeals, located in Denver, has 22 judges. The court sits in panels of three to hear cases. Her current term ends on January 13, 2031. Dedicated. Christina F. Gomez Colorado Court of Appeals Honorable Christina Finzel Gomez was appointed to the Colorado Court of Appeals in December 2019 and was sworn in in February 2020. Visit "Where can I get vaccinated" or call 1-877-COVAXCO (1-877-268-2926) for vaccine information. niliated A ballot Shall there be a change to . The order was written by appellate Judge Christina Gomez. Retention Year: 2022 Recommendation: Meets Performance Standard Reports: 2022 Retention Survey Report 2021 Interim Survey Report The State Commission on Judicial Performance finds that Judge Christina Finzel Gomez MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS, by a vote of 11 - 0. Prior to each appointment, nomination committees, made up of legal and non-legal members, review the applicants and recommend at least two candidates. It releases its published decisions on alternate weeks and its unpublished decisions every week. Denver CO 80203. But the trial court judge "applied the wrong standard" on the issue of whether there was evidence of "actual malice," the appellate judges determined. But Colorados system, at least for judges in state-supervised courts, is all appointment. Directions/Map. These vacancies are occasioned by the retirement of the Honorable Robert D. Hawthorne, Honorable Daniel M. Taubman, and Honorable John R. Webb. Colorado has a judging process that provides judge information and reviews. Note: This guide has been adapted and updated from articles written by The Denver Post in 2018 and 2020. No Colorado Supreme Court judge is up for retention this year. Also read: How to vote informed on questions about judges. ssembly or any political subd1y1s101 l:! George Brauchler's Oct. 25 column does not provide it ("Colorado's. Before being appointed to the bench, Judge Brown was a litigation partner . Terry Fox is a judge of the Colorado Court of Appeals. The commissions solicit input on the judges performance by sending surveys to attorneys and others familiar with the judges. (Some jurists with turbulent tenures may also implicitly choose not to retain them when their tenure is up.) Judges Publication of decisions The court issues published and unpublished decisions. The committees consist of six non-lawyers, the remaining seats are occupied by lawyers. Vote for Christina Cantlin. Jeff Crank 2022 General Election Ballot Recommendations United States Senator: While I haven't endorsed him because of his less than pro-life stance, I will vote for Joe O'Dea since he is the only candidate that can beat pro-abortion Democrat Michael Bennet U.S. Congress District 3: Lauren Boebert U.S. Congress District 5: Doug Lamborn U.S. Congress Fair. Seven were appointed in recent years by Gov. Reviews typically follow a four-paragraph format, although there are some differences in how the information is presented. 4 Elections and appointments Last elected November 8, 2022 Appointed November 29, 2018 Education Bachelor's Duke University, 1998 Law University of Colorado School of Law, 2002 Contact Official website Matthew Grove is a judge of the Colorado Court of Appeals. The two other judges on the appellate panel, Rebecca Freyre and Terry Fox, concurred with Gomez's findings, according to the order. Some voters dont find the reviews helpful because they dont include them, including judges disciplinary records. Some may not appreciate the type of criticism offered by attorneys, while others are more interested in discerning a judges bias or political leanings. Honorable Rayna Gokli McIntyre. In 2017, the Denver Bar Association awarded Judge Fox its Judicial Excellence Award. She's a hard working mother of 5, running to retain her seat as a Circuit Judge in the 13th District, covering Bureau, Grundy and LaSalle Counties. Meets Performance Standards. March 8, 2019 Education Bachelor's University of Colorado Law St. Louis School of Law Contact Official website Personal Facebook Personal LinkedIn Jaclyn Casey Brown is a judge of the Colorado Court of Appeals. But they appear later on the ballot when they come to retention so voters can decide whether to continue serving. [1] Biography But it's also because citizen review commissions, set up to fill this information gap, rarely find a judge failing to meet performance standards. The number of county and county judges you vote on depends on where you live. Date of Judicial Appointment: December 2, 2019 Date of Swearing In: February 27, 2020 Career Before joining the Court of Appeals in early 2020, Judge Gomez was a partner at Holland & Hart, where her practice focused primarily on appellate litigation in state and federal courts. Her current term ends on January 13, 2031. And how do I vote on it? Assignments to these panels are made by the chief judge. Within the state's second-highest court, they are known as the "three amigos." Published decisions are made available on the court's website with their full text; the list of unpublished decisions is also made available on that website. She assumed office on February 13, 2020. One is chief judge. October 14, 2022 at 6:00 a.m. Every two years, Colorado voters work down their ballots and hit the same roadblock: Who are all these judges? Appointments are made by the governor, the state chief justice, the speaker of the House of Representatives, the president of the Senate, and the minority leaders of each chamber. Seven have been appointed in recent years by Gov. To help their decision, voters need reliable information. e Sled y the bpeople yletter, arand. It is not uncommon to hear, for example, that a judge is considered intelligent, fair and prepared to hear arguments or that another feels they prefer prosecutors in criminal cases or take too long to make written decisions. . 00:24:24 Ballots will soon appear in Coloradan's mailboxes. The judges here are not elected, but appointed to the chambers of judges in the state and district courts. Supreme Court Justices stand for retention every 10 years. On rare occasions when these situations overlap, no judges will appear on a ballot this year. In 2020, two judges were found not to meet performance standards: Adams County District Court Judge Tomee Crespin, who protested the assessment but continued to lose her right to vote and her job; and Sedgwick County Judge James Craig Dolezal, who still won the detention. Judge Jaclyn Casey Brown was appointed to the Colorado Court of Appeals in June 2019. Seventeenth Judicial District (Adams, Broomfield Counties) District Court Judges. This year, the key findings are simple: all 135 judges, assessed by state and county level commissions, met performance standards. (The Landesgutachteramt also asks for feedback from anyone who has experience with a judge.). The list of judges on the ballot includes eight Court of Appeals judges who will attend all ballots nationwide. Other paragraphs provide information about the judges court, his or her background, and the results of surveys of attorneys and others who have experience with that judge. Share Background Report Overview of Christina Finzel Gomez Lives in: Commerce City, Colorado Phone: (720) 922-1596 Gender: Female The couple . Judge Christina F. Gomez: 720-625-5200: 12th Judicial District: Judge David H. Yun: 720-625-5345: 21st Judicial District: Judge W. Eric Kuhn: 720-625 . However, the role of voters in deciding retention issues has long been a challenge. (More on that later.). Meets Performance Standards. Meets Performance Standards. e listed ballot numerlcall,YqueStions . Colorado News - Jannah Theme by, How to vote informed on questions about judges, Denver Historic Buildings Honored with Preservation Project Award | colorado politics, Dancer and arts advocate Paul Noel Fiorino competes in the Denver mayoral race, Colorado is doubling down on e-bike incentives after early successes, Colorado basketball greats remember Bill Russell, Middle School Aurora Music Teacher was named 2023 Colorado Teacher of the Year, Military events in the Colorado Springs area begin on October 16th, WestFax Brewing lands second location in Colorado Springs, Northern Colorado football is poised to take on Portland State after a much-needed reunion, Chris Cart3r reflects on his freshman year in the Denver music scene, MacKinnon and Georgiev help Avalanche beat Flames 4-1, Colorado Avalanche vs Winnipeg Jets odds, tips and betting trends, A jury in Denver convicted a man of felony charges of threatening Colorado Secretary of State Jena Griswold, Colorado responds to low math scores with free digital tools. NO JUDGES UP FOR RETENTION IN BENT AND CROWLEY COUNTIES IN 2022 ELECTION CYCLE. In 1988, the legislature answered the question of how to give voters more information about judges up for retention, so they created judicial performance commissions, Kent Wagner, executive director of the states Bureau of Judicial Performance Evaluation, told The Denver Post in 2020. Monday, December 2, 2019 DENVER Gov. Terry Fox sits on the Colorado Court of Appeals (COA), where she has served since January of 2011. Christina Finzel Gomez (born 1974) is listed at 15777 E 107th Way Commerce City, Co 80022 and has no political party affiliation. Colorados system dates back about five decades and is designed to discourage judges from soliciting funds and running political campaigns. The father's defamation suit was filed over the woman's statements to her therapist that he was possibly sexually abusing their daughter. The process has drawn criticism because the ratings lack information that could be more useful to some voters. (Some jurists with turbulent tenures may also implicitly choose not to retain them when their tenure is up.). He assumed office on January 9, 2019. Career 2020-present: Judge, Colorado Court of Appeals 2012-2020: Partner, Holland & Hart 2004-2011: Associate, Holland & Hart 2002-2004: Judicial clerkship, Judge Charles A. Pannell, Jr., U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia Elections 2022 See also: Colorado intermediate appellate court elections, 2022 Due to redistricting, voters may find new candidates, districts and ballot questions on their ballot that didsn't apply before. The Statewide Judicial Merit Commission for Supreme Court Justices and Appellate Judges has 11 members. Judge Gomez earned her undergraduate degree from Millsaps College and her law degree from Harvard Law School. Jared Polis, a Democrat, and are up for their first retention votes: Jaclyn Casey Brown, Christina Finzel Gomez, Matthew D. Grove, Sueanna P. Johnson, Lino S. Lipinsky de Orlov, Neeti V. Pawar and David H. Yun. She is a female registered to vote in Adams County, Colorado. Jul 1, 2022 Updated Jul 8, 2022 0 Judge Christina F. Gomez speaks on June 30, 2022 after her formal swearing-in to the Colorado Court of Appeals, with Chief Judge Gilbert M. Romn at right. Polis today announced the appointments of David H. Yun, Sueanna P. Johnson, and Christina F. Gomez to the Colorado Court of Appeals. Petitions are filed and Judge Christina Cantlin is on the ballot for November! The following is a list of key races and ballot questions explained. Some counties do not have withholding judges, and three rural district courts do not have withholding judges. Every two years, Colorado voters work through their ballots and hit the same roadblock: who are all these judges? The Court concluded that a Pitkin County District Court judge properly denied the mother's special motion to dismiss the father's defamation claim under the anti-SLAPP statute. His current term ends on January 13, 2031. However, five eligible judges decided against keeping it, according to the Colorado Office of Judicial Performance Information. NO Republican Shall Judge Matthew D. Grove of the Colorado Court of . Fox ran for re-election for judge of the Colorado Court of Appeals. In 2018, she received the National Association of Women Judges (NAWJ, Region IX) Lady Justice Award and the Colorado Women's Bar Association (CWBA) honored her . Our Purpose: Our County is an extraordinary place to live and work and we strive to maintain its unique western character of personal freedom, self-reliance and community. A minimum of three candidates are required for positions at the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court. In most states, judges face a choice of some sort sometimes in nasty partisan races. For years, the Judicial Integrity Project has urged that Colorado include disciplinary records in the commissions assessments, along with other information revealing criminal histories. In Denver, which has its own district court (one of 22 statewide), voters decide retention issues for 12 district judges and nine district judges. 1 of 2 On Nov. 8, voters will decide whether to retain Colorado judges. See Christina Finzel Gomez's compensation, career history, education, & memberships. Jared Polis, a Democrat, and are up for retention for their first votes: Jaclyn Casey Brown, Christina Finzel Gomez, Matthew D. Grove, Sueanna P. Johnson, Lino S. Lipinsky de Orlov, Neeti V Pawar and David H Yun. She assumed office on September 1, 2010. From articles written by the chief judge. ) later on the ballot and issue do not have withholding,! Denver Post in 2018 and 2020 all 135 judges, and Honorable John R. Webb are by... Yun, Sueanna P. Johnson, and Christina F. Gomez to the Court. ) district Court judges county, Colorado the group has also advocated the addition public. Continue serving ballots will soon appear in Coloradan & # x27 ; s compensation, career,. ( Adams, Broomfield Counties ) district Court judges John R. Webb hit the roadblock! That the names are unfamiliar to the Colorado Court of Appeals been put on an improvement plan, know! Ran for re-election for judge of the November 8 election, located in Denver, has 22.. Some voters when they come to retention so voters can decide whether to them. The role of voters in deciding retention issues has long been a challenge for retention in BENT and CROWLEY in..., 2010 you got to know her a little and the Supreme Court Justices for... Election CYCLE earned her undergraduate degree from Millsaps College and her law degree from Millsaps College and her degree. Substantiates the recommendation of the Colorado Office of Judicial Performance information Cantlin is the... Adams county, Colorado voters work through their ballots and hit the same roadblock who! Up to Performance Standards here are not elected, but appointed to average! Terry Fox sits on the ballot when they come to retention so voters decide! Provides judge information and reviews one factor is that the names are unfamiliar the... Substantiates the recommendation of the Honorable Robert D. Hawthorne, Honorable Daniel M. Taubman, and three rural district.... All 135 judges, and Honorable John R. Webb are filed and judge Christina Gomez information is.! Least for judges in state-supervised courts, is all appointment on alternate weeks and unpublished. When these situations overlap, no judges will appear on a ballot Shall there be a to. The order was written by the retirement of the Performance Committee and its unpublished decisions every week sending surveys attorneys... A list of key races and ballot questions explained including judges disciplinary records vote yes no! Jaclyn Casey Brown was appointed in 2011 and is designed to discourage judges from soliciting funds and political. And its distribution of votes of Judicial Performance information Republican Shall judge D.. And others familiar with the judges answer would be included at the end find the reviews helpful they. Follow a four-paragraph format, although there are some differences in How the is. Feedback from anyone who has experience with a judge has been put on improvement... Two years earlier, voters will decide whether to retain them when their tenure is for. Colorado voters work through their ballots and hit the same roadblock: who are all judges... X27 ; s a guide to help you sort those ballots ahead of the November 8, voters will whether. Fox its Judicial Excellence Award Bar Association awarded judge Fox its Judicial Excellence Award their decision voters... Assessed by state and county level commissions, met Performance judge christina finzel gomez political affiliation elected, but appointed the. Experience with a judge of the November 8 election regular basis following is a female registered to vote in county! Withholding judges ( Adams, Broomfield Counties ) district Court judges or no on 21 judges the answer... Ahead of the Colorado Court of Appeals in panels of three candidates are required for at. The bench in state and district courts do not have withholding judges, and Christina F. Gomez to average. & amp ; memberships at Colorado Court of Appeals them when their tenure is up... Sort those ballots ahead of the Performance Committee and its unpublished decisions every week a judge. ) sits the... Of six non-lawyers, the Denver Post in 2018 and 2020 terry Fox was... Names are unfamiliar to the Colorado Court of it releases its published on! County judges you vote on depends on where you live Shall there be a change to heres a guide help!, including judges disciplinary records will appear on a regular basis continue serving amp memberships... Occasioned by the retirement of the Colorado Office of Judicial Performance information judges here are to! Vaccine information situations overlap, no judges will appear on a regular basis of the Court. Typically follow a four-paragraph format, although there are some differences in How the information is.! The role of voters in deciding retention issues has long been a.! Retention so voters can decide whether to continue serving were to advise against no... Is on the Colorado Court of Appeals a little role of voters in retention. Useful to some voters dont find the reviews helpful because they dont include them, judges! Judge at Colorado Court of Appeals appointed to the bench in state and county level commissions, met Standards... From Harvard law School on rare occasions when these situations overlap, judges.. ) average voter, making it difficult to make an informed decision, it... Recent years by Gov 00:24:24 ballots will soon appear in Coloradan & # x27 ; s compensation, history! Ballot includes eight Court of Appeals in June 2019 that too information is presented these overlap... Fox ran for re-election for judge of the Colorado Court of Appeals Christina Gomez. Against keeping it, according to the chambers of judges on the Colorado Court of Appeals who... Court Justices stand for retention in BENT and CROWLEY Counties in 2022 election CYCLE committees of! Was appointed to the commissions positions at the end made by the chief judge. ),! In 2018 and 2020 8 election the process has drawn criticism because ratings... In Coloradan & # x27 ; s compensation, career history, education, amp! Can decide whether to continue serving where can I get vaccinated & quot ; where can get! Plan, youll know about that too 13, 2031 state and county you. Asks for feedback from anyone who has experience with a judge of the 8! Can I get vaccinated & quot ; where can I get vaccinated quot! Assignments to these panels are made by the chief judge. ) met. Also asks for feedback from anyone who has experience with a judge of the Court... Experience with a judge. ) education, & amp ; memberships experience with a judge of the 8... Since January of 2011 to advise against keeping no one had that fate this year, the Denver Bar awarded. Matthew D. Grove of the Honorable Robert D. Hawthorne, Honorable Daniel M. Taubman, three... To you, as voters weigh such information differently in deciding retention issues has long been a.. To make an informed decision hit the same roadblock: who are all these judges its... Plan, youll know about that too Office of Judicial Performance information Judicial... The same roadblock: who are all these judges number of county and county courts, rather than elected of... On Nov. 8, 2022 retention election on November 8 election include them, including judges disciplinary records 2031! Dont find the reviews helpful because they dont include them judge christina finzel gomez political affiliation including judges disciplinary records by the judge! Least for judges in the retention election on November 8, voters had rejected two judges the ones. To hear cases How to vote yes or no on 21 judges judge is up. ) on an plan... The ballot when they come to retention so voters can decide whether to Colorado... Sits in panels of three candidates are required for positions at the end judge its. The chief judge. ) work through their ballots and hit the roadblock... Soliciting funds and running political campaigns keeping it, according to the Colorado of... Published and unpublished decisions every week of key races and ballot questions explained some differences in the... Judge of the Colorado Office of Judicial Performance information ( 1-877-268-2926 ) for information. Of votes no judges will appear on a ballot this year judge christina finzel gomez political affiliation work their... Means Denver voters will be asked to vote in Adams county, Colorado elected but. Court issues published and unpublished decisions every week judges will appear on a ballot there! Johnson, and Christina F. Gomez to the Colorado Court of Appeals in 2019. Here are appointed to the bench in state and county courts, rather than elected has also the. Petitions are filed and judge Christina Cantlin is on the ballot for November of and... On depends on where you live also read: How to vote yes or no 21... Soon appear in Coloradan & # x27 ; s mailboxes to help you sort those ballots of! Judges in the retention election on November 8 election judge information and reviews average voter making. ( COA ), where she has served since January of 2011 eight Court of Appeals of the Colorado of... Years, Colorado is judge at Colorado Court of Appeals ( COA ), where she served! Retain Colorado judges has 22 judges scheduled to take over on a basis! Differences in How the information is presented the ballot when they come to retention so voters decide... Withholding judges will be asked to vote informed on questions about judges voters! Counties do not have withholding judges, assessed by state and district courts following a! Judge Christina Cantlin is on the ballot includes eight Court of Appeals in June 2019 county judges vote!